Today, Presidential Candidate Andrew Yang released a slew of tech proposals, covering four main issues:
- Privacy and Consumer Data
- The Use of Technology, Especially by Young People
- Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act
- Antitrust Enforcement and Tech
Privacy and Consumer Data
“The current online advertising model enables consumers to access high quality content and sophisticated services for free. Yang’s policy would create more paywalls around content and diminish the presence of free services.”
“On Yang’s internet we will have more paywalls and less content.”
“Americans support the current market structure. By a 3-to-1 margin Americans prefer online services to be funded by targeted advertising rather than paying for them directly.”
The Use of Technology, Especially by Young People
“The surge in access to technology and the internet in the 21st Century benefits us all every day – that’s why tech is so prevalent in society today.”
“For a candidate who claims to focus on “evidence-based policy,” Yang’s most outlandish claims lack evidence.”
“Rather than proposing knee-jerk policy responses to perceived problems, Yang should wait for more evidence on tech’s impact on children and not ignore a recent study that found no link between social media usage and negative impacts on mental health in teens.”
Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act
“We must dispel with this myth that because online services moderate user-created content, they are equivalent to the New York Times or the Washington Post. Unlike the journalists at the New York Times or Washington Post, Facebook doesn’t write posts and Twitter doesn’t write tweets — users do.”
“The New York Times and the Washington Post’s comment section benefits from the same legal structure and protections as social media businesses.”
“Social media services moderate content to reduce the presence of hate speech, scams, and spam. Yang’s proposal to amend Section 230 would likely increase the amount of hate speech and terrorist content online.”
“Yang incorrectly claims a “publisher vs. platform grey area.” Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act does not categorize online services. Section 230 enables services that host user-created content to remove content without assuming liability.”
Antitrust Enforcement and Tech
“We welcome Yang’s recognition that breaking up tech businesses wouldn’t benefit consumers. The role of antitrust and regulation in the U.S. is to protect consumers, not competitors of successful businesses.”