Close this menu

NetChoice v. Rokita (Indiana)

Key Takeaways:
  • Every Hoosier gets carded, not just kids. HEA 1408 requires covered websites to determine the age and Indiana residency of everyone who wants an account, then re-verify users’ ages as their time online grows. Anyone the platform flags as possibly under 16, adults included, gets 30 days to prove their age with records tied to a mortgage, schooling, or job, or the account is terminated.
  • The state overrides parents instead of empowering them. Even after a parent says yes, Indiana locks teen accounts into state-chosen settings, switching off personalized feeds and features the government has labeled “addictive.” Parents already have strong tools to make these choices for their own families.
  • Courts have repeatedly blocked laws like this. Federal courts have stopped similar age-verification and parental-consent laws in Arkansas, Utah, and Louisiana, and Indiana’s should fall too.
What's At Stake
  • The First Amendment and access to lawful speech online.
  • Hoosiers' data privacy and security.
  • The right of parents and guardians to parent their children online.
  • Meaningful and legal protections, not mandated I.D.'s for the internet, for all Hoosiers' online safety.
Case Brief

Case Status: Complaint filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Indiana, Indianapolis Division

Latest Update: November 18, 2026

Attorneys:

  • Paul Clement
  • Erin Murphy
  • James Xi
  • Jeff Thalhofer


Firms:
Clement Murphy

Timeline
  • U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Indiana, Indianapolis Division
    November 18, 2026: Complaint filed

Indiana has joined the age-verification discussion, siding with the U.K., Europe, and Australia. In other words, Indiana is imposing a one-size-fits-all mandate on everyone in the state who wants to use popular online speech services.

NetChoice’s newest lawsuit challenges the social media provisions of HEA 1408, a law that will require covered websites to determine the age and Indiana residency of every user, adult or teen, before they can open or keep an account. Users will face repeated age checks for up to a decade, and even when parents give permission, the state, not families, will decide how teen accounts work. Federal courts have blocked similar laws in Arkansas, Utah, and Louisiana. This is an ID-for-Speech law, and it violates the First Amendment.

Any user flagged as possibly under 16, adult or teen, has 30 days to prove their age or lose their account. They can prove it with parental consent or with “transactional data” such as mortgage, education, or employment records. The law requires platforms to delete parental-consent information but not the transactional data. That creates a honeypot for hackers and identity thieves and threatens the anonymous speech that many Americans rely on, including whistleblowers, abuse survivors, and users looking for sensitive health information.

HEA 1408 also overrides parents instead of empowering them. Even with a parent’s permission, the state turns off personalized recommendations and disables features it labels “addictive.” Those are editorial choices the Supreme Court protected in Moody v. NetChoice. A parent can’t let their teen get recommendations for coding tutorials or college-prep content. Teens in foster care or living with relatives who aren’t their legal guardians could be cut off entirely. NetChoice’s Digital Safety Shield for America offers a better path forward with legal and meaningful solutions that protect families online without harming the rights of all Hoosiers.

Court Filings

NetChoice’s complaint filed on November 18, 2026, in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Indiana, Indianapolis Division.